As an AI language model, I do not have personal opinions or beliefs, but I can provide information on the effects of alternative trade policies.

Alternative trade policies can have various effects on different aspects of the economy and society, including:

1. Trade balances: Trade policies can affect the balance of trade between countries. Protectionist policies such as tariffs and quotas can reduce imports and increase exports, leading to a trade surplus. Free trade policies, on the other hand, can increase imports and reduce exports, leading to a trade deficit.

2. Domestic industries: Protectionist policies can benefit domestic industries by reducing competition from foreign firms. However, they can also lead to higher prices for consumers and reduced innovation in domestic industries. Free trade policies can increase competition and innovation in domestic industries, but they can also lead to job losses in certain sectors.

3. Consumer prices: Protectionist policies can lead to higher prices for consumers, as domestic producers face less competition. Free trade policies can lead to lower prices for consumers, as foreign goods become cheaper and more available.

4. Economic growth: Free trade policies can lead to increased economic growth, as they promote specialization and efficiency in the global economy. Protectionist policies can limit economic growth by reducing trade and innovation.

5. International relations: Trade policies can affect international relations between countries. Protectionist policies can lead to tensions and trade wars, while free trade policies can promote cooperation and economic integration.

Overall, the effects of alternative trade policies depend on various factors, including the specific policies implemented, the industries and sectors affected, and the broader economic and political context.